Besides being an incredible drummer who showed his talent with Genesis and as a solo artist, Phil Collins was also a fantastic songwriter and singer. But he also proved that he could write successful piano ballads, which gave him even more room to explore different possibilities in his music. Throughout his career, he had the chance to meet and watch many incredible pianists perform, including Elton John, about whom he has already shared his opinion.
What is Phil Collins’ opinion on Elton John
“I was a big (fan of Elton since the beginning). I like the second one (album – self-titled 1970), which was his first popular album, with the ‘Border song’. That was my favorite song of his at that time. “Your Song”, “Sixty Years On”, all those things were great. ‘Tumbleweed Connection’, I’d liked particularly because at the time I was listening to The Band as well. I thought that Bernie’s lyrics and the kind of chords and the feel of ‘Tumbleweed Connection’ reminded me a bit of The Band.”
“His style of piano playing, I’m very sympathetic to. I like the kind of chords he uses, I guess that’s what started me off. That’s the kind of thing I was starting to try to play like when I used to listen to his records, I would start playing the piano. I was quite late in playing the piano. If Elton feels that he doesn’t write as good lyrics as Bernie does or Bernie doesn’t write music, then I think it’s a perfect combination. You know your weakness and you can find someone else that has that strength. That’s the way to do it,” Phil Collins said in the documentary “Two Rooms” in 1990 (Transcribed by Rock and Roll Garage).
Phil and Elton are really good friends and the drummer has already described him as a musician at heart and a muso, saying that he loves him. This is what he wrote in his autobiography when sharing a photo of himself with Elton after winning the Oscar for Best Original Song for “You’ll Be in My Heart”.
He said:
“Oscar night, 2000. I’d seen Elton at a MusiCares event the week before. He’d told me where his Oscar party was going to be. And that if I got lucky, as he believed I would, I was to come and show off. I did get lucky and I went to his party, Oscar firmly in hand. Elton was so excited for me. He’s a lovely, lovely guy, and a real musician at heart. All he wants to do is play the piano. There’s a certain amount of preening that comes with it, but deep inside he’s a muso. I love him,” Phil Collins said in his book “Not Dead Yet”.
Collins had a chance to honor Elton a few weeks before at the MusiCares, when elected Person of the Year. During the ceremony Collins sang “Burn Down the Mission”, from the album “Tumbleweed Connection” (1970). He had previously covered the track on an Elton and Taupin tribute album. During an interview before that performance he described Elton as a lovely man and one of the best.
Collins once humorously recalled the Elton phase when he was “dressing like a duck and wearing glasses bigger than his
In his book, there is also a funny passage in which Phil recalls some of the strange things musicians were doing on stage at the time. He mentions Elton, saying he was “dressing like a duck and wearing glasses bigger than his head.” They first met each other in the 1980s and there was an interesting occasion in 1986. Collins was with Elton as the musician was feeling insecure about performing.
“In Australia our routing overlaps with that of Elton John, and I spend an instructive evening in his dressing room in Melbourne. He’s playing with the Melbourne Symphony, and it’ll be broadcast all over Australia. Elton throws a moody because he thinks he’s lost his voice. It looks like he’s about to pull the gig, no matter how this might impact on the dozens of orchestral players and the tens of thousands of fans. He calls for his limo, is driven round the car park in a low-speed huff, but in the end comes back and takes the stage.”
“Post-show, back in his dressing room. I tell him I only noticed a slight vocal wobble in one place, during ‘Don’t Let the Sun Go Down On Me’. He’s pleased to hear that, but I sense a tantrum remains but a tickly tonsil away. For me, it’s an illuminating interlude. Most times the audience just don’t notice these subtleties. I’d barely noticed and I knew he was hoarse. You need to think twice before letting a sore throat mushroom into a diva-shaped cancellation. There are few excuses that will cut it with 20,000 fans, short of actually dying in the steam room pre-gig,” he said in his autobiography.
How Elton John’s previous work with Disney inspired Phil to accept their offer for “Tarzan”
One of Disney’s most successful modern classics, “The Lion King”, released in 1994, certainly wouldn’t have been the same without the original songs written by Elton John and Tim Rice. Three songs were nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Song. They were “Circle of Life”, “Hakuna Matata” and “Can You Feel the Love Tonight”, which ultimately won the award.
“(…) 1995 – this is the year Elton John, my near peer, has won an Oscar, a Grammy and a Golden Globe for his work on the soundtrack for The Lion King. So when, as a songwriter, you get a phone call saying Disney want you to write for them, you think, ‘My God, I’m being asked to join a club I never thought I’d become a member of. (…) Afterwards (MusiCares), in the Elton receiving area, he and I discuss the upcoming Oscars. And what he felt when he won for ‘Can You Feel the Love Tonight’. What I will feel if I’m lucky enough to win. He tells me he felt ‘f*cking great’,” Phil Collins recalled in his book.
Phil Collins old friend Ray Cooper is a longtime member of Elton’s band
The most sought-after percussionist in British Rock, Ray Cooper played with almost all of the biggest musicians from the UK. He played with George Harrison, Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, Pink Floyd, Rolling Stones, Eric Clapton, Mark Knopfler and more. He’s been a member of Elton’s band on and off since 1973. Besides the 70s, he worked with him in the 80s, 90s and from 2009 on.
Cooper and Collins are old friends and as he already said, both he and Elton love him as a musician. “Elton John’s preferred percussionist, Ray Cooper, is a great player who can really push it, then push it some more. There was blood on the walls.” (Referring to how long he keeps playing, to the point where his hands might bleed.) “No wonder Elton loves him,” he said in “Not Dead Yet”.

